My guess is he's just serving dressed in the choir cassock of a bishop; he could then be serving as master of ceremonies at an important liturgy in the Vatican. The overcoat doesn't quite match, so the man is probably just walking across the courtyard with the surplice (?) showing.
Scott is right (as always). AND, the tailoring is probably not Roman because the piping is paonazza and not red. Prelates (of honour and otherwise) have red piping and lining to both the abito piano and the abito corale. It can't be papal MC with incorrect piping and a bishop's biretta WITHOUT pom-pom. As we know, there are all sorts of people wandering around Rome. Who took the picture and when?
Until the owner of the blog cares to look things up (mr. Sonnen took the picture if I'm not mistaken), we can continue speculating. I've never got the piping details thoroughly explained to me, but as things have been in the Church for decades - who's to say for certain what really is when things of varying importance have been disregarded or confused for so long?
I have NEVER seen such piping on a Roman-made cassock. This "matching" piping is typical of american-style cassocks.
Who... the Law of the Church, which regulates prelatial vesture. No Roman ecclesiastical taylor would make such a cassock. As for the biretta, he may have simply removed the pom-pom.
What could John have "looked up" about this photo? Significant enough that such a photo has been put on the web, provoking our discussion.
i took the photo of this guy while we were leaving the vatican basilica after vespers with the pope on new years eve. i just figured he was some poser as he's surely too young to be a bishop...
BTW, prelates of honour wear black birettas with black pom-poms. Protonotaries Apostolic de numero can wear an amarath-red pom pom on their BLACK birettas. Paonazza birettas are only for bishops. Ergo, he is not DRESSED as a prelate of honour. In ogni caso, the piping is still wrong. and the jacket...?!
I suspect that this very handsome cleric is a prefect of ceremonies as his vesture suggests. As to his colourful biretta, perhaps he has the right to wear it under some ancient but little used indult. No doubt it was cold after vespers and he right put on an overcoat.
According to the 1888 "Praeclaro divinae gratiae" of Leo XIII, bishops, archbishops and patriarchs must wear a purple biretta. All lesser prelates have to wear a black biretta with either a red or a purple tuft according to their rank.
This man cannot be a bishop. You will never see a bishop wearing a biretta without a tuft. The piping on his cassock is pink rather than red, though the top button looks red.
it seems to be episcopal livery i.e. one who has no true choir cassock of which to speak, acting as MC for the bishop is entitled to wear a cassock such as this, the biretta, maybe he felt left out so decided for this rather fetching biretta
I'm a graduate student and tour operator living in Rome, Italy. Life is good. Studium Urbis! P.S. To know history is to be Catholic. P.P.S. Schedule your tour with us while in Rome.
J.P. Sonnen is an author, history docent, educator and travel writer. His graduate degrees are from the Pontifical University of St. Thomas Aquinas (Angelicum) in Rome, Italy.
16 comments:
Who his His Excellency on this picture?
He seems awfully young to be bishop - must be at least 35, though ;-)
Who is that man, someone bound for a diplomatic position in a forsaken province in Gwuarkacengo?
Further info wished for.
Where's the pom-pom?
Yes, the lack of pom-pom makes me think this is not actually a bishop...
Interesting vestiture also, the black overcoat over choir dress.
My guess is he's just serving dressed in the choir cassock of a bishop; he could then be serving as master of ceremonies at an important liturgy in the Vatican.
The overcoat doesn't quite match, so the man is probably just walking across the courtyard with the surplice (?) showing.
Scott is right (as always). AND, the tailoring is probably not Roman because the piping is paonazza and not red. Prelates (of honour and otherwise) have red piping and lining to both the abito piano and the abito corale. It can't be papal MC with incorrect piping and a bishop's biretta WITHOUT pom-pom. As we know, there are all sorts of people wandering around Rome. Who took the picture and when?
Until the owner of the blog cares to look things up (mr. Sonnen took the picture if I'm not mistaken), we can continue speculating.
I've never got the piping details thoroughly explained to me, but as things have been in the Church for decades - who's to say for certain what really is when things of varying importance have been disregarded or confused for so long?
I have NEVER seen such piping on a Roman-made cassock. This "matching" piping is typical of american-style cassocks.
Who... the Law of the Church, which regulates prelatial vesture. No Roman ecclesiastical taylor would make such a cassock. As for the biretta, he may have simply removed the pom-pom.
What could John have "looked up" about this photo? Significant enough that such a photo has been put on the web, provoking our discussion.
The man is a prelate of honour, not a bishop.
i took the photo of this guy while we were leaving the vatican basilica after vespers with the pope on new years eve. i just figured he was some poser as he's surely too young to be a bishop...
I think you're right, John.
BTW, prelates of honour wear black birettas with black pom-poms. Protonotaries Apostolic de numero can wear an amarath-red pom pom on their BLACK birettas. Paonazza birettas are only for bishops. Ergo, he is not DRESSED as a prelate of honour.
In ogni caso, the piping is still wrong. and the jacket...?!
foolish child forgot to wear his greca...somebody in the blogosphere surely is going to know this guy...hilarious!
I suspect that this very handsome cleric is a prefect of ceremonies as his vesture suggests. As to his colourful biretta, perhaps he has the right to wear it under some ancient but little used indult. No doubt it was cold after vespers and he right put on an overcoat.
According to the 1888 "Praeclaro divinae gratiae" of Leo XIII, bishops, archbishops and patriarchs must wear a purple biretta. All lesser prelates have to wear a black biretta with either a red or a purple tuft according to their rank.
This man cannot be a bishop. You will never see a bishop wearing a biretta without a tuft. The piping on his cassock is pink rather than red, though the top button looks red.
it seems to be episcopal livery i.e. one who has no true choir cassock of which to speak, acting as MC for the bishop is entitled to wear a cassock such as this, the biretta, maybe he felt left out so decided for this rather fetching biretta
He may be a student at a Roman college. Students wearing a similar cassock served the Papal Mass for the opening of the Holy Door on 8 December 2015.
Post a Comment